04
Nov 24

Are Vitamins Better than Psychotropic Medicines?

Teenager“…adding a vitamin where there is no deficiency will not cure a disease that has a different source.”

Sooner or later, it seems like many parents of mentally ill teens ask themselves this question. When the medicine seems to bring only miserable side effects, it’s natural to ask ourselves if maybe we’ve missed the obvious. Even if the medicine has brought your teen relief, you may be dissatisfied that it hasn’t brought greater improvement.

A couple of summers ago, I browsed through a book on holistic medicine while I was visiting my mom. It said that people with bipolar disorder don’t absorb sufficient B vitamins, especially B12.  Since my son has bipolar disorder and I was always looking for new answers, I went to the health the food store and bought some vitamin B. After all, how could it hurt?

The B-complex I bought was called something like “Stress Tabs.” The irony of the name was lost on me until about a month later when my son complained that his anxiety was worsening. After a month of no improvement, I became suspicious of the vitamins and removed them. Within a couple of weeks, his anxiety had come back down. I’m glad I didn’t buy him a B12 shot as the book had suggested! The following summer, I had all of my son’s vitamin B levels checked during his blood work. To my surprise, they were all on the high side–including the B12. Lesson learned. I should have started with blood work and gotten some real information before rushing to buy something that seemed harmless.

Severe vitamin deficiencies can cause all sorts of symptoms. But adding a vitamin where there is no deficiency will not cure a disease that has a different source. If you suspect a deficiency, ask your doctor to test for it during blood work.

 


04
Nov 24

Can There be Too Many Healing Interventions?

Teenager“…choose a few effective and tolerable interventions and then stick with them…”

Your teen is cooperating by attending therapy, participating in a teen support group, taking medicine, practicing yoga, swallowing fish oil pills, and maintaining a journal of feelings. A friend tells you that a gluten-free diet might help and a family member urges you to try healing touch therapy.

Can too many interventions be risky? I believe so.

Too many rigors in the life of a young person can lead to the teen declaring, “I’m not doing any of this anymore!” As adults, it can be easy to forget that teens are freshly out of childhood, unaccustomed to doing much more self-care than dressing and brushing their teeth.Throw too much at them and they may rebel.

But there’s an even greater risk. Some teens may welcome additional interventions, filling their lives with ever more treatment and leaving little time to simply be a teen. Your son or daughter may become a “professional patient,” whereby they define themselves only by their illness. Yet, your growing teen still has the task of developing friendships, creative outlets, academics, and career goals.

The solution is to choose a few effective and tolerable interventions and then stick with them, while letting your teen get on with the other important parts of life. I’m not knocking a gluten-free diet or touch therapy, but consider the impact of introducing a new strategy if the current plan is working. If well-meaning, loving relatives suggest additional strategies, thank them for their help and support and say you’ll keep the information in mind.